Not working. Need to investigate.

2022-01-07 17:24:20 -07:00

14 KiB

Raw Blame History

The purpose of this list is to track and compare tunneling solutions. This is primarily targeted toward self-hosters and developers who want to do things like exposing a local webserver via a public domain name, with automatic HTTPS, even if behind a NAT or other restricted network.

The dream

I started this list because I'm looking for a simple tool/service that does the following:

Allows me to register a domain name and automatically points the records at the server running the tunnels.
Automatically sets up and manages HTTPS certificates (apex and subdomains) for the domain.
Provides a client tool that tunnels HTTP/TCP connections through the server without requiring root on the client.
Provides a simple GUI interface to allow me to map X domain/subdomain to Y port on Z client, and proxy all connections to that domain.

So far I haven't found a tool that does all of this. In particular, while some of them can do automatic certs through Lets's Encrypt, none of them integrate the domain registration and DNS management.

UPDATE: Since starting this list I found most of the other solutions to be either too complicated or making different tradeoffs than I would want. I have two of my own projects in this space:

SirTunnel is I believe the minimal way of getting auto-HTTPS tunneled through to a private network. It's just a 50-line Python script that leverages Caddy and OpenSSH, but you need to understand how it works to use it. This one is good for developers.
boringproxy is my take on a comprehensive tunnel proxy solution. It's in beta but currently solves almost everything I want except auto DNS management, and that's planned. Once the server is running this is a very easy tool to use, and is targeted at non-developers.

Open source (at least with a reasonably permissive license)

frp - Comprehensive open alternative to ngrok. Supports UDP, and has a P2P mode. I believe it uses a custom TCP protocol for multiplexing, which can either run over a single TCP connection or a connection pool.
ngrok 1.0 - Original version of ngrok. No longer developed in favor of the commercial 2.0 version.
localtunnel - Written in node. Popular suggestion.
Nebula - Peer-to-peer overlay network. Developed and used internally by Slack. Similar to Tailscale but completely open source. Written in Go.
ZeroTier - Layer 2 overlay network.
sshuttle - Open source project originally from one of the founders of Tailscale. Server doesn't require root; client does. Explicitly designed to avoid TCP-over-TCP issues.
chisel - SSH under the hood, but still uses a custom client binary. Supports auto certs from LetsEncrypt. Written in Go.
expose - ngrok alternative written in PHP.
Pritunl - Seems quite comprehensive and complicated. OpenVPN, WireGuard, and IPSec support.
teleconsole - SSH-based, but uses special client script. Focused on forwarding SSH console sessions, but can also forward ports.
go-http-tunnel - Uses a single HTTP/2 connection for muxing. Need to manually generate certs for server and clients.
sish - Open source ngrok/serveo alternative. SSH-based but uses a custom server written in Go. Supports WebSocket tunneling.
rathole - Similar to frp, including the config format, but with improved performance. Low resource consumption. Hot reload. Written in Rust.
tunnelto - Open source (MIT). Written in Rust.
wstunnel - Proxies over WebSockets. Focus on proxying from behind networks that block certain protocols. Written in Haskell with executables provided.
PageKite - Comprehensive open source solution with hosted options.
Crowbar - Tunnels TCP connections over HTTP GET and POST requests.
tunneller - Open source. Written in Go.
jprq - Proxies over WebSockets. Written in Python.
boringproxy - Designed to be very easy to use. No config files. Clients can be remote-controlled through a simple WebUI and/or REST API on the server.
tunnel - This one is a Golang library, not a program you can just run. However, it looks easy to use for creating custom solutions. Uses a single TCP socket, and yamux for multiplexing.
pgrok - Fork of ngrok 1.0, with more recent commits.
SirTunnel - Minimal, self-hosted, 0-config alternative to ngrok. Similar to sish but leverages Caddy+OpenSSH rather than custom server code.
docker-tunnel - Simple Docker-based nginx+SSH solution.
remotemoe - SSH-based, with custom golang server. Does some cool unique things. Instead of just plain tunnels, it drops you into a basic CLI UI that offers several useful commands interactively, such as adding a custom hostname. Also allows end-to-end encryption for both HTTPS and upstream SSH. Doesn't appear to offer non-e2e HTTPS, ie no auto Let's Encrypt support.
holepunch.io - Has nice hosted solution. Uses SSH for muxing.
StaqLab Tunnel - SSH-based. Client is open source. Server doesn't appear to be.
tnnlink - SSH-based. Golang. Not maintained.
Telebit - Written in JS. Code.
SSH-J.com - Public SSH Jump & Port Forwarding server. No software, no registration, just an anonymous SSH server for forwarding. Users are encouraged to use it for SSH exposure only, to preserve end-to-end encryption. No public ports, only in-SSH connectivity. Run ssh ssh-j.com and it will display usage information.
Ngrok-operator - Ngrok but integrated with Kubernetes, allows developers on private kubernetes to easily access their services via Ngrok.

Commercial/Closed source

ngrok 2.0 - Probably the gold standard and most popular. Closed source. Lots of features, including TLS and TCP tunnels. Doesn't require root to run client.
CloudFlare Tunnel - Excellent free option. Nicely integrates tunneling with the rest of Cloudflare's products, which include DNS and auto HTTPS. Client source code is available.
Tailscale - Built on WireGuard. Easy to use. Doesn't include an HTTPS proxy on the public side, but could be combined with nginx/Caddy/etc. Client code available with a BSD3 license + separate patents file.
Loophole - Offers end-to-end TLS encryption with the client automatically getting certs from Let's Encrypt. QR codes for URL sharing. Client is open source. Can serve a local directory over WebDAV. MIT License. Written in Go.
localhost.run - Simple hosted SSH option. Supports custom domains for a cost.
Packetriot - Comprehensive alternative to ngrok. HTTP Inspector, Let's Encrypt integration, doesn't require root and Linux repos for apt, yum and dnf. Enterprise licenses and self-hosted option.
Hoppy - WireGuard-based. Provides static IPv4 and IPv6 addresses for your machines, which is a simple and useful level of abstraction. Targeted towards self-hosters and people behind NATs.
gw.run - Specifically focusing on securely exposing internal web apps to a group of people; not for publicly facing apps. Share access via email address then allow users to log in with common login providers like Google.
SSHReach.me - Paid SSH-based option. Uses a simple python script.
KubeSail - Company offering tunneling, dynamic DNS, and other services for self-hosting with Kubernetes.
inlets - Used to be open source; now focused on a polished commercial offering. Designed to work well with Kubernetes.
LocalToNet - Supports UDP. Free for a single tunnel. Paid supports custom domains.

Reference

Discussions

HN comment about needing Namecheap + CloudFlare + ngrok.