beenull/sftpgo
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

Add performance summary

Browse source 
Pull request #92
This commit is contained in:
HiFiPhile 2020-03-06 22:48:55 +01:00 committed by Nicola Murino
parent 61f20f5449
commit 7221bf9b25
2 changed files with 179 additions and 4 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

4
README.md
View file

@ -160,9 +160,7 @@ Details information about account configuration properties can be found [here](.
## Performance ## Performance
SFTPGo can easily saturate a Gigabit connection on low end hardware with no special configuration, and this is generally enough for most use cases. SFTPGo can easily saturate a Gigabit connection on low end hardware with no special configuration, this is generally enough for most use cases.
The main bootlenecks are the encryption and the messages authentication, so if you can use a fast cipher with implicit message authentication, for example `aes128-gcm@openssh.com`, you will get a big performance boost.
More in-depth analysis of performance can be found [here](./docs/performance.md). More in-depth analysis of performance can be found [here](./docs/performance.md).

179
docs/performance.md
View file

@ -1,3 +1,180 @@
# Performance # Performance
There is an open [issue](https://github.com/drakkan/sftpgo/issues/69) with some other suggestions to improve performance and some comparisons against OpenSSH. SFTPGo can easily saturate a Gigabit connection on low end hardware with no special configuration, this is generally enough for most use cases.
For Multi-Gig connections, some performance improvements and comparisons with OpenSSH have been discussed [here](https://github.com/drakkan/sftpgo/issues/69), some of them need upstream updates so there are not included in the SFTPGo released version (0.9.6) yet. To summarize:
- In current state with all performance improvements applied, SFTP performance is very close to OpenSSH however CPU usage is higher. SCP performance match OpenSSH.
- The main bottlenecks are the encryption and the messages authentication, so if you can use a fast cipher with implicit messages authentication, such as `aes128-gcm@openssh.com`, you will get a big performance boost.
- SCP protocol is much simpler than SFTP and so, the multi-platform, SFTPGo's SCP implementation performs better than SFTP.
- Load balancing with HAProxy can greatly improve the performance if CPU not become the bottleneck.
## Benchmark
### Hardware specification
**Server** ||
--- | --- |
OS| Debian 10.2 x64 |
CPU| Ryzen5 3600 |
RAM| 64GB 2400MHz ECC |
Disk| 3* Intel P4510 4TB RAID0 |
Ethernet| Mellanox ConnectX-3 40GbE|
**Client** ||
--- | --- |
OS| Ubuntu 19.10 x64 |
CPU| Threadripper 1920X |
RAM| 64GB 2400MHz ECC |
Disk| Samsung 960EVO 1TB |
Ethernet| Mellanox ConnectX-3 40GbE|
### Test configurations
- `Baseline`: SFTPGo version 0.9.6.
- `Optimized`: Various [optimizations](#Optimizations-applied) applied on top of 0.9.6.
- `Balanced`: Two optimized instances, running on localhost, load balanced by HAProxy 2.1.3.
- `OpenSSH`: OpenSSH_7.9p1 Debian-10+deb10u2, OpenSSL 1.1.1d 10 Sep 2019
Server's CPU is in Eco mode, you can expect better results in certain cases with a stronger CPU, especially multi-stream HAProxy balanced load.
#### Cipher aes128-ctr
The Message Authentication Code (MAC) used is `hmac-sha2-256`.
##### SFTP
Download:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|149|306|370|378|
2|265|576|675|720|
3|341|807|880|1002|
4|402|1024|1150|1222|
8|518|1749|1400|1815|
Upload:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|165|292|340|355|
2|262|453|490|633|
3|327|566|560|726|
4|376|647|650|788|
8|478|735|700|806|
##### SCP
Download:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|215|509|579|470|
2|433|928|1097|828|
3|613|1327|1346|1174|
4|824|1670|1576|1424|
8|1281|2656|2049|1870|
Upload:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|189|354|393|428|
2|312|510|570|668|
3|401|621|664|803|
4|481|705|723|840|
8|652|767|799|884|
#### Cipher aes128gcm@openssh.com
With this cipher the messages authentication is implicit, no SHA256 computation is needed.
##### SFTP
Download:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|322|388|561|401|
2|518|734|976|810|
3|638|1067|1214|1072|
4|723|1283|1415|1288|
8|844|2072|1742|1842|
Upload:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|318|353|415|381|
2|473|542|573|670|
3|569|672|657|757|
4|621|730|721|758|
8|694|825|763|815|
##### SCP
Download:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|669|734|818|447|
2|1218|1320|1367|883|
3|1752|1738|1755|1217|
4|2202|2238|2038|1475|
8|3151|3184|2391|1941|
Upload:
Stream|Baseline MB/s|Optimized MB/s|Balanced MB/s|OpenSSH MB/s|
---|---|---|---|---|
1|446|446|494|448|
2|616|623|646|650|
3|746|749|728|741|
4|833|832|788|858|
8|897|903|823|887|
### Optimizations applied
- AES-CTR optimization of Golang compiler, the patch hasn't been merged yet, you can apply it yourself. [Patch](https://go-review.googlesource.com/c/go/+/51670)
- Use [minio/sha256-simd](https://github.com/minio/sha256-simd) to accelerate MAC (Message Authentication Code) computation. In this way the tested hardware will use `Intel SHA Extensions` for SHA256 computation. This will give a significant performance boost compared to `AVX2` extensions used with the Golang's SHA256 implementation.
```
diff --git a/go.mod b/go.mod
index f1b2caa..109e064 100644
--- a/go.mod
+++ b/go.mod
@@ -43,3 +43,5 @@ require (
)
replace github.com/eikenb/pipeat v0.0.0-20190316224601-fb1f3a9aa29f => github.com/drakkan/pipeat v0.0.0-20200123131427-11c048cfc0ec
+
+replace golang.org/x/crypto => github.com/drakkan/crypto v0.0.0-20200303175438-17ef3d252b1c
```
- A new allocator for `pkg/sftp` which greatly improve parallel loads. We are discussing about this patch with `pkg/sftp` maintainers [here](https://github.com/pkg/sftp/issues/334).
```
diff --git a/go.mod b/go.mod
index 109e064..4d67a47 100644
--- a/go.mod
+++ b/go.mod
@@ -45,3 +45,4 @@ require (
replace github.com/eikenb/pipeat v0.0.0-20190316224601-fb1f3a9aa29f => github.com/drakkan/pipeat v0.0.0-20200123131427-11c048cfc0ec
replace golang.org/x/crypto => github.com/drakkan/crypto v0.0.0-20200303175438-17ef3d252b1c
+replace github.com/pkg/sftp => github.com/drakkan/sftp v0.0.0-20200227085621-6b4abaad1b9a
```
### HAProxy configuration
Here is the relevant HAProxy configuration used for the `Balanced` test configuration:
```
frontend sftp
bind :2222
mode tcp
timeout client 600s
default_backend sftpgo
backend sftpgo
mode tcp
balance roundrobin
timeout connect 10s
timeout server 600s
timeout queue 30s
option tcp-check
tcp-check expect string SSH-2.0-
server sftpgo1 127.0.0.1:2022 check send-proxy-v2 weight 10 inter 10s rise 2 fall 3
server sftpgo2 127.0.0.1:2024 check send-proxy-v2 weight 10 inter 10s rise 2 fall 3
```