To accomplish this, we add another VeilState which is called
LockedInherited. The idea is to apply exec unveil data, similar to
execpromises of the pledge syscall, on the current exec'ed program
during the execve sequence. When applying the forced unveil data, the
veil state is set to be locked but the special state of LockedInherited
ensures that if the new program tries to unveil paths, the request will
silently be ignored, so the program will continue running without
receiving an error, but is still can only use the paths that were
unveiled before the exec syscall. This in turn, allows us to use the
unveil syscall with a special utility to sandbox other userland programs
in terms of what is visible to them on the filesystem, and is usable on
both programs that use or don't use the unveil syscall in their code.
We now disallow jail creation from a process within a jail because there
is simply no valid use case to allow it, and we will probably not enable
this behavior (which is considered a bug) again.
Although there was no "real" security issue with this bug, as a process
would still be denied to join that jail, there's an information reveal
about the amount of jails that are or were present in the system.
Our implementation for Jails resembles much of how FreeBSD jails are
working - it's essentially only a matter of using a RefPtr in the
Process class to a Jail object. Then, when we iterate over all processes
in various cases, we could ensure if either the current process is in
jail and therefore should be restricted what is visible in terms of
PID isolation, and also to be able to expose metadata about Jails in
/sys/kernel/jails node (which does not reveal anything to a process
which is in jail).
A lifetime model for the Jail object is currently plain simple - there's
simpy no way to manually delete a Jail object once it was created. Such
feature should be carefully designed to allow safe destruction of a Jail
without the possibility of releasing a process which is in Jail from the
actual jail. Each process which is attached into a Jail cannot leave it
until the end of a Process (i.e. when finalizing a Process). All jails
are kept being referenced in the JailManagement. When a last attached
process is finalized, the Jail is automatically destroyed.
This is intended to reflect the POSIX sched_setparam API, which has some
cryptic language
(https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/functions/V2_chap02.html#tag_15_08_04_01
) that as far as I can tell implies we should prioritize process
scheduling policies over thread scheduling policies. Technically this
means that a process must have its own sets of policies that are
considered first by the scheduler, but it seems unlikely anyone relies
on this behavior in practice. So we just override all thread's policies,
making them (at least before calls to pthread_setschedparam) behave
exactly like specified on the surface.
The syscalls are renamed as they no longer reflect the exact POSIX
functionality. They can now handle setting/getting scheduler parameters
for both threads and processes.
Previously we didn't send the SIGPIPE signal to processes when
sendto()/sendmsg()/etc. returned EPIPE. And now we do.
This also adds support for MSG_NOSIGNAL to suppress the signal.
The idea is to enable mounting FileSystem objects across multiple mounts
in contrast to what happened until now - each mount has its own unique
FileSystem object being attached to it.
Considering a situation of mounting a block device at 2 different mount
points at in system, there were a couple of critical flaws due to how
the previous "design" worked:
1. BlockBasedFileSystem(s) that pointed to the same actual device had a
separate DiskCache object being attached to them. Because both instances
were not synchronized by any means, corruption of the filesystem is most
likely achieveable by a simple cache flush of either of the instances.
2. For superblock-oriented filesystems (such as the ext2 filesystem),
lack of synchronization between both instances can lead to severe
corruption in the superblock, which could render the entire filesystem
unusable.
3. Flags of a specific filesystem implementation (for example, with xfs
on Linux, one can instruct to mount it with the discard option) must be
honored across multiple mounts, to ensure expected behavior against a
particular filesystem.
This patch put the foundations to start fix the issues mentioned above.
However, there are still major issues to solve, so this is only a start.
Although this code worked quite well, it is considered to be a code
duplication with the TmpFS code which is more tested and works quite
well for a variety of cases. The only valid reason to keep this
filesystem was that it enforces that no regular files will be created at
all in the filesystem. Later on, we will re-introduce this feature in a
sane manner. Therefore, this can be safely removed after SystemServer no
longer uses this filesystem type anymore.
Now that AddressSpace itself is always SpinlockProtected, we don't
need to also wrap the RegionTree. Whoever has the AddressSpace locked
is free to poke around its tree.
This allows sys$mprotect() to honor the original readable & writable
flags of the open file description as they were at the point we did the
original sys$mmap().
IIUC, this is what Dr. POSIX wants us to do:
https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/functions/mprotect.html
Also, remove the bogus and racy "W^X" checking we did against mappings
based on their current inode metadata. If we want to do this, we can do
it properly. For now, it was not only racy, but also did blocking I/O
while holding a spinlock.
Before this change, we had File::mmap() which did all the work of
setting up a VMObject, and then creating a Region in the current
process's address space.
This patch simplifies the interface by removing the region part.
Files now only have to return a suitable VMObject from
vmobject_for_mmap(), and then sys$mmap() itself will take care of
actually mapping it into the address space.
This fixes an issue where we'd try to block on I/O (for inode metadata
lookup) while holding the address space spinlock. It also reduces time
spent holding the address space lock.
This forces anyone who wants to look into and/or manipulate an address
space to lock it. And this replaces the previous, more flimsy, manual
spinlock use.
Note that pointers *into* the address space are not safe to use after
you unlock the space. We've got many issues like this, and we'll have
to track those down as wlel.
This makes locking them much more straightforward, and we can remove
a bunch of confusing use of AddressSpace::m_lock. That lock will also
be converted to use of SpinlockProtected in a subsequent patch.
Boot profiling was previously broken due to init_stage2() passing the
event mask to sys$profiling_enable() via kernel pointer, but a user
pointer is expected.
To fix this, I added Process::profiling_enable() as an alternative to
Process::sys$profiling_enable which takes a u64 rather than a
Userspace<u64 const*>. It's a bit of a hack, but it works.
Instead of temporary changing the open file description's "blocking"
flag while doing a non-waiting recvfrom, we instead plumb the currently
wanted blocking behavior all the way through to the underlying socket.
Instead of getting credentials from Process::current(), we now require
that they be provided as input to the various VFS functions.
This ensures that an atomic set of credentials is used throughout an
entire VFS operation.
This ensures that both mutable and immutable access to the protected
data of a process is serialized.
Note that there may still be multiple TOCTOU issues around this, as we
have a bunch of convenience accessors that make it easy to introduce
them. We'll need to audit those as well.
By protecting all the RefPtr<Custody> objects that may be accessed from
multiple threads at the same time (with spinlocks), we remove the need
for using LockRefPtr<Custody> (which is basically a RefPtr with a
built-in spinlock.)
Instead, allocate when acquiring the lock on m_fds struct, which is
safer to do in terms of safely mutating the m_fds struct, because we
don't use the big process lock in this syscall.
This patch adds the NGROUPS_MAX constant and enforces it in
sys$setgroups() to ensure that no process has more than 32 supplementary
group IDs.
The number doesn't mean anything in particular, just had to pick a
number. Perhaps one day we'll have a reason to change it.
Now that these operate on the neatly atomic and immutable Credentials
object, they should no longer require the process big lock for
synchronization. :^)
