123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111112113114115116117118119120121122123124125126127128129130131132133134135136137138139140141142143144145146147148149150151152153154155156157158159160161162163164165166167168169170171172173174175176177178179180181182183184185186187188189190191192193194195196197198199200201202203204205206207208209210211212213214215216217218219220221222223224225226227228229230231232233234235236237238239240241242243244245246247248249250251252253254255256257258259260261262263264265266267268269270271272273274275276277278279280281282283284285286287288289290291292293294295296297298299300301302303304305306307308309310311312313314315316317318319320321322323324325326327328329330331332333334335336337338339340341342343344345346347348349350351352353354355356357358359360361362363364365366367368369370371372373374375376377378379380381382383384385386387388389390391392393394395396397398399400401402403404405406407408409410411412413414415416417418419420421422423424425426427428429430431432433434435436437438439440441442443444445446447448449450451452453454455456457458459460461462463464465466467468469470471472473474475476477478479480481482483484485486487488489490491492493494495496497498499500501502503504505506507508509510511512513514515516517518519520521522523524525526527528529530531532533534535536537538539540541542543544545546547548549550551552553554555556557558559560561562563564565566567568569570571572573574575576577578579580581582583584585586587588589590591592593594595596597598599600601602603604605606607608609610611612613614615616617618619620621622623624625626627628629630 |
- /*
- * Copyright (c) 2020, Ali Mohammad Pur <mpfard@serenityos.org>
- *
- * SPDX-License-Identifier: BSD-2-Clause
- */
- #include <AK/Base64.h>
- #include <AK/Debug.h>
- #include <AK/Endian.h>
- #include <LibCore/ConfigFile.h>
- #include <LibCore/DateTime.h>
- #include <LibCore/File.h>
- #include <LibCore/StandardPaths.h>
- #include <LibCore/Timer.h>
- #include <LibCrypto/ASN1/ASN1.h>
- #include <LibCrypto/ASN1/PEM.h>
- #include <LibCrypto/Curves/Ed25519.h>
- #include <LibCrypto/Curves/SECPxxxr1.h>
- #include <LibCrypto/PK/Code/EMSA_PKCS1_V1_5.h>
- #include <LibCrypto/PK/Code/EMSA_PSS.h>
- #include <LibFileSystem/FileSystem.h>
- #include <LibTLS/Certificate.h>
- #include <LibTLS/TLSv12.h>
- #include <errno.h>
- #ifndef SOCK_NONBLOCK
- # include <sys/ioctl.h>
- #endif
- namespace TLS {
- void TLSv12::consume(ReadonlyBytes record)
- {
- if (m_context.critical_error) {
- dbgln("There has been a critical error ({}), refusing to continue", (i8)m_context.critical_error);
- return;
- }
- if (record.size() == 0) {
- return;
- }
- dbgln_if(TLS_DEBUG, "Consuming {} bytes", record.size());
- if (m_context.message_buffer.try_append(record).is_error()) {
- dbgln("Not enough space in message buffer, dropping the record");
- return;
- }
- size_t index { 0 };
- size_t buffer_length = m_context.message_buffer.size();
- size_t size_offset { 3 }; // read the common record header
- size_t header_size { 5 };
- dbgln_if(TLS_DEBUG, "message buffer length {}", buffer_length);
- while (buffer_length >= 5) {
- auto length = AK::convert_between_host_and_network_endian(ByteReader::load16(m_context.message_buffer.offset_pointer(index + size_offset))) + header_size;
- if (length > buffer_length) {
- dbgln_if(TLS_DEBUG, "Need more data: {} > {}", length, buffer_length);
- break;
- }
- auto consumed = handle_message(m_context.message_buffer.bytes().slice(index, length));
- if constexpr (TLS_DEBUG) {
- if (consumed > 0)
- dbgln("consumed {} bytes", consumed);
- else
- dbgln("error: {}", consumed);
- }
- if (consumed != (i8)Error::NeedMoreData) {
- if (consumed < 0) {
- dbgln("Consumed an error: {}", consumed);
- if (!m_context.critical_error)
- m_context.critical_error = (i8)consumed;
- m_context.error_code = (Error)consumed;
- break;
- }
- } else {
- continue;
- }
- index += length;
- buffer_length -= length;
- if (m_context.critical_error) {
- dbgln("Broken connection");
- m_context.error_code = Error::BrokenConnection;
- break;
- }
- }
- if (m_context.error_code != Error::NoError && m_context.error_code != Error::NeedMoreData) {
- dbgln("consume error: {}", (i8)m_context.error_code);
- m_context.message_buffer.clear();
- return;
- }
- if (index) {
- // FIXME: Propagate errors.
- m_context.message_buffer = MUST(m_context.message_buffer.slice(index, m_context.message_buffer.size() - index));
- }
- }
- bool Certificate::is_valid() const
- {
- auto now = Core::DateTime::now();
- if (now < validity.not_before) {
- dbgln("certificate expired (not yet valid, signed for {})", validity.not_before.to_byte_string());
- return false;
- }
- if (validity.not_after < now) {
- dbgln("certificate expired (expiry date {})", validity.not_after.to_byte_string());
- return false;
- }
- return true;
- }
- // https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc5280.html#page-12
- bool Certificate::is_self_signed()
- {
- if (m_is_self_signed.has_value())
- return *m_is_self_signed;
- // Self-signed certificates are self-issued certificates where the digital
- // signature may be verified by the public key bound into the certificate.
- if (!this->is_self_issued)
- m_is_self_signed.emplace(false);
- // FIXME: Actually check if we sign ourself
- m_is_self_signed.emplace(true);
- return *m_is_self_signed;
- }
- void TLSv12::try_disambiguate_error() const
- {
- dbgln("Possible failure cause(s): ");
- switch ((AlertDescription)m_context.critical_error) {
- case AlertDescription::HANDSHAKE_FAILURE:
- if (!m_context.cipher_spec_set) {
- dbgln("- No cipher suite in common with {}", m_context.extensions.SNI);
- } else {
- dbgln("- Unknown internal issue");
- }
- break;
- case AlertDescription::INSUFFICIENT_SECURITY:
- dbgln("- No cipher suite in common with {} (the server is oh so secure)", m_context.extensions.SNI);
- break;
- case AlertDescription::PROTOCOL_VERSION:
- dbgln("- The server refused to negotiate with TLS 1.2 :(");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::UNEXPECTED_MESSAGE:
- dbgln("- We sent an invalid message for the state we're in.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::BAD_RECORD_MAC:
- dbgln("- Bad MAC record from our side.");
- dbgln("- Ciphertext wasn't an even multiple of the block length.");
- dbgln("- Bad block cipher padding.");
- dbgln("- If both sides are compliant, the only cause is messages being corrupted in the network.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::RECORD_OVERFLOW:
- dbgln("- Sent a ciphertext record which has a length bigger than 18432 bytes.");
- dbgln("- Sent record decrypted to a compressed record that has a length bigger than 18432 bytes.");
- dbgln("- If both sides are compliant, the only cause is messages being corrupted in the network.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::DECOMPRESSION_FAILURE_RESERVED:
- dbgln("- We sent invalid input for decompression (e.g. data that would expand to excessive length)");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::ILLEGAL_PARAMETER:
- dbgln("- We sent a parameter in the handshake that is out of range or inconsistent with the other parameters.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::DECODE_ERROR:
- dbgln("- The message we sent cannot be decoded because a field was out of range or the length was incorrect.");
- dbgln("- If both sides are compliant, the only cause is messages being corrupted in the network.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::DECRYPT_ERROR:
- dbgln("- A handshake crypto operation failed. This includes signature verification and validating Finished.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::ACCESS_DENIED:
- dbgln("- The certificate is valid, but once access control was applied, the sender decided to stop negotiation.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::INTERNAL_ERROR:
- dbgln("- No one knows, but it isn't a protocol failure.");
- break;
- case AlertDescription::DECRYPTION_FAILED_RESERVED:
- case AlertDescription::NO_CERTIFICATE_RESERVED:
- case AlertDescription::EXPORT_RESTRICTION_RESERVED:
- dbgln("- No one knows, the server sent a non-compliant alert.");
- break;
- default:
- dbgln("- No one knows.");
- break;
- }
- dbgln("- {}", enum_to_value((AlertDescription)m_context.critical_error));
- }
- void TLSv12::set_root_certificates(Vector<Certificate> certificates)
- {
- if (!m_context.root_certificates.is_empty()) {
- dbgln("TLS warn: resetting root certificates!");
- m_context.root_certificates.clear();
- }
- for (auto& cert : certificates) {
- if (!cert.is_valid()) {
- dbgln("Certificate for {} is invalid, things may or may not work!", cert.subject.to_string());
- }
- // FIXME: Figure out what we should do when our root certs are invalid.
- m_context.root_certificates.set(MUST(cert.subject.to_string()).to_byte_string(), cert);
- }
- dbgln_if(TLS_DEBUG, "{}: Set {} root certificates", this, m_context.root_certificates.size());
- }
- static bool wildcard_matches(StringView host, StringView subject)
- {
- if (host == subject)
- return true;
- if (subject.starts_with("*."sv)) {
- auto maybe_first_dot_index = host.find('.');
- if (maybe_first_dot_index.has_value()) {
- auto first_dot_index = maybe_first_dot_index.release_value();
- return wildcard_matches(host.substring_view(first_dot_index + 1), subject.substring_view(2));
- }
- }
- return false;
- }
- static bool certificate_subject_matches_host(Certificate const& cert, StringView host)
- {
- if (wildcard_matches(host, cert.subject.common_name()))
- return true;
- for (auto& san : cert.SAN) {
- if (wildcard_matches(host, san))
- return true;
- }
- return false;
- }
- bool Context::verify_chain(StringView host) const
- {
- if (!options.validate_certificates)
- return true;
- Vector<Certificate> const* local_chain = nullptr;
- if (is_server) {
- dbgln("Unsupported: Server mode");
- TODO();
- } else {
- local_chain = &certificates;
- }
- if (local_chain->is_empty()) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Attempting to verify an empty chain");
- return false;
- }
- // RFC5246 section 7.4.2: The sender's certificate MUST come first in the list. Each following certificate
- // MUST directly certify the one preceding it. Because certificate validation requires that root keys be
- // distributed independently, the self-signed certificate that specifies the root certificate authority MAY be
- // omitted from the chain, under the assumption that the remote end must already possess it in order to validate
- // it in any case.
- if (!host.is_empty()) {
- auto const& first_certificate = local_chain->first();
- auto subject_matches = certificate_subject_matches_host(first_certificate, host);
- if (!subject_matches) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: First certificate does not match the hostname");
- return false;
- }
- } else {
- // FIXME: The host is taken from m_context.extensions.SNI, when is this empty?
- dbgln("FIXME: verify_chain called without host");
- return false;
- }
- for (size_t cert_index = 0; cert_index < local_chain->size(); ++cert_index) {
- auto const& cert = local_chain->at(cert_index);
- auto subject_string = MUST(cert.subject.to_string());
- auto issuer_string = MUST(cert.issuer.to_string());
- if (!cert.is_valid()) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Certificate is not valid {}", subject_string);
- return false;
- }
- auto maybe_root_certificate = root_certificates.get(issuer_string.to_byte_string());
- if (maybe_root_certificate.has_value()) {
- auto& root_certificate = *maybe_root_certificate;
- auto verification_correct = verify_certificate_pair(cert, root_certificate);
- if (!verification_correct) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Signature inconsistent, {} was not signed by {} (root certificate)", subject_string, issuer_string);
- return false;
- }
- // Root certificate reached, and correctly verified, so we can stop now
- return true;
- }
- if (subject_string == issuer_string) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Non-root self-signed certificate");
- return options.allow_self_signed_certificates;
- }
- if ((cert_index + 1) >= local_chain->size()) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: No trusted root certificate found before end of certificate chain");
- dbgln("verify_chain: Last certificate in chain was signed by {}", issuer_string);
- return false;
- }
- auto const& parent_certificate = local_chain->at(cert_index + 1);
- if (issuer_string != MUST(parent_certificate.subject.to_string())) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Next certificate in the chain is not the issuer of this certificate");
- return false;
- }
- if (!(parent_certificate.is_allowed_to_sign_certificate && parent_certificate.is_certificate_authority)) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: {} is not marked as certificate authority", issuer_string);
- return false;
- }
- if (parent_certificate.path_length_constraint.has_value() && cert_index > parent_certificate.path_length_constraint.value()) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Path length for certificate exceeded");
- return false;
- }
- bool verification_correct = verify_certificate_pair(cert, parent_certificate);
- if (!verification_correct) {
- dbgln("verify_chain: Signature inconsistent, {} was not signed by {}", subject_string, issuer_string);
- return false;
- }
- }
- // Either a root certificate is reached, or parent validation fails as the end of the local chain is reached
- VERIFY_NOT_REACHED();
- }
- bool Context::verify_certificate_pair(Certificate const& subject, Certificate const& issuer) const
- {
- Crypto::Hash::HashKind kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::Unknown;
- auto identifier = subject.signature_algorithm.identifier;
- bool is_rsa = true;
- if (identifier == rsa_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::None;
- } else if (identifier == rsa_md5_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::MD5;
- } else if (identifier == rsa_sha1_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA1;
- } else if (identifier == rsa_sha256_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA256;
- } else if (identifier == rsa_sha384_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA384;
- } else if (identifier == rsa_sha512_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA512;
- } else if (identifier == ecdsa_with_sha256_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA256;
- is_rsa = false;
- } else if (identifier == ecdsa_with_sha384_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA384;
- is_rsa = false;
- } else if (identifier == ecdsa_with_sha512_encryption_oid) {
- kind = Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA512;
- is_rsa = false;
- }
- if (kind == Crypto::Hash::HashKind::Unknown) {
- dbgln("verify_certificate_pair: Unknown signature algorithm, expected RSA or ECDSA with SHA1/256/384/512, got OID {}", identifier);
- return false;
- }
- if (is_rsa) {
- Crypto::PK::RSAPrivateKey dummy_private_key;
- Crypto::PK::RSAPublicKey public_key_copy { issuer.public_key.rsa };
- auto rsa = Crypto::PK::RSA(public_key_copy, dummy_private_key);
- auto verification_buffer_result = ByteBuffer::create_uninitialized(subject.signature_value.size());
- if (verification_buffer_result.is_error()) {
- dbgln("verify_certificate_pair: Unable to allocate buffer for verification");
- return false;
- }
- auto verification_buffer = verification_buffer_result.release_value();
- auto verification_buffer_bytes = verification_buffer.bytes();
- rsa.verify(subject.signature_value, verification_buffer_bytes);
- ReadonlyBytes message = subject.tbs_asn1.bytes();
- auto pkcs1 = Crypto::PK::EMSA_PKCS1_V1_5<Crypto::Hash::Manager>(kind);
- auto verification = pkcs1.verify(message, verification_buffer_bytes, subject.signature_value.size() * 8);
- return verification == Crypto::VerificationConsistency::Consistent;
- }
- // ECDSA hash verification: hash, then check signature against the specific curve
- switch (issuer.public_key.algorithm.ec_parameters) {
- case SupportedGroup::SECP256R1: {
- Crypto::Hash::Manager hasher(kind);
- hasher.update(subject.tbs_asn1.bytes());
- auto hash = hasher.digest();
- Crypto::Curves::SECP256r1 curve;
- auto result = curve.verify(hash.bytes(), issuer.public_key.raw_key, subject.signature_value);
- if (result.is_error()) {
- dbgln("verify_certificate_pair: Failed to check SECP256r1 signature {}", result.release_error());
- return false;
- }
- return result.value();
- }
- case SupportedGroup::SECP384R1: {
- Crypto::Hash::Manager hasher(kind);
- hasher.update(subject.tbs_asn1.bytes());
- auto hash = hasher.digest();
- Crypto::Curves::SECP384r1 curve;
- auto result = curve.verify(hash.bytes(), issuer.public_key.raw_key, subject.signature_value);
- if (result.is_error()) {
- dbgln("verify_certificate_pair: Failed to check SECP384r1 signature {}", result.release_error());
- return false;
- }
- return result.value();
- }
- case SupportedGroup::X25519: {
- Crypto::Curves::Ed25519 curve;
- auto result = curve.verify(issuer.public_key.raw_key, subject.signature_value, subject.tbs_asn1.bytes());
- if (!result) {
- dbgln("verify_certificate_pair: Failed to check Ed25519 signature");
- return false;
- }
- return result;
- }
- default:
- dbgln("verify_certificate_pair: Don't know how to verify signature for curve {}", to_underlying(issuer.public_key.algorithm.ec_parameters));
- return false;
- }
- }
- template<typename HMACType>
- static void hmac_pseudorandom_function(Bytes output, ReadonlyBytes secret, u8 const* label, size_t label_length, ReadonlyBytes seed, ReadonlyBytes seed_b)
- {
- if (!secret.size()) {
- dbgln("null secret");
- return;
- }
- auto append_label_seed = [&](auto& hmac) {
- hmac.update(label, label_length);
- hmac.update(seed);
- if (seed_b.size() > 0)
- hmac.update(seed_b);
- };
- HMACType hmac(secret);
- append_label_seed(hmac);
- constexpr auto digest_size = hmac.digest_size();
- u8 digest[digest_size];
- auto digest_0 = Bytes { digest, digest_size };
- digest_0.overwrite(0, hmac.digest().immutable_data(), digest_size);
- size_t index = 0;
- while (index < output.size()) {
- hmac.update(digest_0);
- append_label_seed(hmac);
- auto digest_1 = hmac.digest();
- auto copy_size = min(digest_size, output.size() - index);
- output.overwrite(index, digest_1.immutable_data(), copy_size);
- index += copy_size;
- digest_0.overwrite(0, hmac.process(digest_0).immutable_data(), digest_size);
- }
- }
- void TLSv12::pseudorandom_function(Bytes output, ReadonlyBytes secret, u8 const* label, size_t label_length, ReadonlyBytes seed, ReadonlyBytes seed_b)
- {
- // Simplification: We only support the HMAC PRF with the hash function SHA-256 or stronger.
- // RFC 5246: "In this section, we define one PRF, based on HMAC. This PRF with the
- // SHA-256 hash function is used for all cipher suites defined in this
- // document and in TLS documents published prior to this document when
- // TLS 1.2 is negotiated. New cipher suites MUST explicitly specify a
- // PRF and, in general, SHOULD use the TLS PRF with SHA-256 or a
- // stronger standard hash function."
- switch (hmac_hash()) {
- case Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA512:
- hmac_pseudorandom_function<Crypto::Authentication::HMAC<Crypto::Hash::SHA512>>(output, secret, label, label_length, seed, seed_b);
- break;
- case Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA384:
- hmac_pseudorandom_function<Crypto::Authentication::HMAC<Crypto::Hash::SHA384>>(output, secret, label, label_length, seed, seed_b);
- break;
- case Crypto::Hash::HashKind::SHA256:
- hmac_pseudorandom_function<Crypto::Authentication::HMAC<Crypto::Hash::SHA256>>(output, secret, label, label_length, seed, seed_b);
- break;
- default:
- dbgln("Failed to find a suitable HMAC hash");
- VERIFY_NOT_REACHED();
- break;
- }
- }
- TLSv12::TLSv12(StreamVariantType stream, Options options)
- : m_stream(move(stream))
- {
- m_context.options = move(options);
- m_context.is_server = false;
- m_context.tls_buffer = {};
- set_root_certificates(m_context.options.root_certificates.has_value()
- ? *m_context.options.root_certificates
- : DefaultRootCACertificates::the().certificates());
- setup_connection();
- }
- Vector<Certificate> TLSv12::parse_pem_certificate(ReadonlyBytes certificate_pem_buffer, ReadonlyBytes rsa_key) // FIXME: This should not be bound to RSA
- {
- if (certificate_pem_buffer.is_empty() || rsa_key.is_empty()) {
- return {};
- }
- auto decoded_certificate = Crypto::decode_pem(certificate_pem_buffer);
- if (decoded_certificate.is_empty()) {
- dbgln("Certificate not PEM");
- return {};
- }
- auto maybe_certificate = Certificate::parse_certificate(decoded_certificate);
- if (!maybe_certificate.is_error()) {
- dbgln("Invalid certificate");
- return {};
- }
- Crypto::PK::RSA rsa(rsa_key);
- auto certificate = maybe_certificate.release_value();
- certificate.private_key = rsa.private_key();
- return { move(certificate) };
- }
- static Vector<ByteString> s_default_ca_certificate_paths;
- void DefaultRootCACertificates::set_default_certificate_paths(Span<ByteString> paths)
- {
- s_default_ca_certificate_paths.clear();
- s_default_ca_certificate_paths.ensure_capacity(paths.size());
- for (auto& path : paths)
- s_default_ca_certificate_paths.unchecked_append(path);
- }
- DefaultRootCACertificates::DefaultRootCACertificates()
- {
- auto load_result = load_certificates(s_default_ca_certificate_paths);
- if (load_result.is_error()) {
- dbgln("Failed to load CA Certificates: {}", load_result.error());
- return;
- }
- m_ca_certificates = load_result.release_value();
- }
- DefaultRootCACertificates& DefaultRootCACertificates::the()
- {
- static DefaultRootCACertificates s_the;
- return s_the;
- }
- ErrorOr<Vector<Certificate>> DefaultRootCACertificates::load_certificates(Span<ByteString> custom_cert_paths)
- {
- auto cacert_file_or_error = Core::File::open("/etc/cacert.pem"sv, Core::File::OpenMode::Read);
- ByteBuffer data;
- if (!cacert_file_or_error.is_error())
- data = TRY(cacert_file_or_error.value()->read_until_eof());
- #ifdef AK_OS_SERENITY
- else
- return cacert_file_or_error.release_error();
- #endif
- auto user_cert_path = TRY(String::formatted("{}/.config/certs.pem", Core::StandardPaths::home_directory()));
- if (FileSystem::exists(user_cert_path)) {
- auto user_cert_file = TRY(Core::File::open(user_cert_path, Core::File::OpenMode::Read));
- TRY(data.try_append(TRY(user_cert_file->read_until_eof())));
- }
- for (auto& custom_cert_path : custom_cert_paths) {
- if (FileSystem::exists(custom_cert_path)) {
- auto custom_cert_file = TRY(Core::File::open(custom_cert_path, Core::File::OpenMode::Read));
- TRY(data.try_append(TRY(custom_cert_file->read_until_eof())));
- }
- }
- return TRY(parse_pem_root_certificate_authorities(data));
- }
- ErrorOr<Vector<Certificate>> DefaultRootCACertificates::parse_pem_root_certificate_authorities(ByteBuffer& data)
- {
- Vector<Certificate> certificates;
- auto certs = TRY(Crypto::decode_pems(data));
- for (auto& cert : certs) {
- auto certificate_result = Certificate::parse_certificate(cert.bytes());
- if (certificate_result.is_error()) {
- // FIXME: It would be nice to have more informations about the certificate we failed to parse.
- // Like: Issuer, Algorithm, CN, etc
- dbgln("Failed to load certificate: {}", certificate_result.error());
- continue;
- }
- auto certificate = certificate_result.release_value();
- if (certificate.is_certificate_authority && certificate.is_self_signed()) {
- TRY(certificates.try_append(move(certificate)));
- } else {
- dbgln("Skipped '{}' because it is not a valid root CA", TRY(certificate.subject.to_string()));
- }
- }
- dbgln("Loaded {} of {} ({:.2}%) provided CA Certificates", certificates.size(), certs.size(), (certificates.size() * 100.0) / certs.size());
- return certificates;
- }
- }
|