ENODEV better represents the fact that there might be no display device
(e.g. a monitor) connected to the connector, therefore we should return
this error.
Another reason to not use ENOTIMPL is that it's a requirement for all
DisplayConnectors to put a valid EDID in place even for a hardware we
don't currently support mode-setting in runtime.
In the real world, graphics hardware tend to have multiple display
connectors. However, usually the connectors share one register space but
still keeping different PLL timings and display lanes.
This new class should represent a group of multiple display connectors
working together in the same Intel graphics adapter. This opens an
opportunity to abstract the interface so we could support future Intel
iGPU generations.
This is also a preparation before the driver can support newer devices
and utilize their capabilities.
The mentioned preparation is applied in a these aspects:
1. The code is splitted into more classes to adjust to future expansion.
2 classes are introduced: IntelDisplayPlane and IntelDisplayTranscoder,
so the IntelDisplayPlane controls the plane registers and second class
controls the pipeline (transcoder, encoder) registers. On gen4 it's not
really useful because there are probably one plane and one encoder to
care about, but in future generations, there are likely to be multiple
transcoders and planes to accommodate multi head support.
2. The set_edid_bytes method in the DisplayConnector class can now be
told to not assume the provided EDID bytes are always invalid. Therefore
it can refrain from printing error messages if this flag parameter is
true. This is useful for supporting real hardware situation when on boot
not all ports are connected to a monitor, which can result in floating
bus condition (essentially all the bytes we read are 0xFF).
3. An IntelNativeDisplayConnector could now be set to flag other types
of connections such as eDP (embedded DisplayPort), Analog output, etc.
This is important because on the Intel gen4 graphics we could assume to
have one analog output connector, but on future generations this is very
likely to not be the case, as there might be no VGA outputs, but rather
only an eDP connector which is converted to VGA by a design choice of
the motherboard manufacturer.
4. Add ConnectorIndex to IntelNativeDisplayConnector class - Currently
this is used to verify we always handle the correct connector when doing
modesetting.
Later, it will be used to locate special settings needed when handling
connector requests.
5. Prepare to support more types of display planes. For example, the
Intel Skylake register set for display planes is a bit different, so
let's ensure we can properly support it in the near future.
This header has always been fundamentally a Kernel API file. Move it
where it belongs. Include it directly in Kernel files, and make
Userland applications include it via sys/ioctl.h rather than directly.
We try our best to ensure a DisplayConnector initialization succeeds,
and this makes the Intel driver to work again, because if we can't
allocate a Region for the whole PCI BAR mapped region, then we will try
to allocate a Region with 16 MiB window size, so it doesn't eat the
entire Kernel-allocated virtual memory space.
Instead of just returning nothing, let's return Error or nothing.
This would help later on with error propagation in case of failure
during this method.
This also makes us more paranoid about failure in this method, so when
initializing a DisplayConnector we safely tear down the internal members
of the object. This applies the same for a StorageDevice object, but its
after_inserting method is much smaller compared to the DisplayConnector
overriden method.
This value will be used later on by WindowServer to reject resolutions
that will request a mapping that will overflow the hardware framebuffer
max length.
Before this change, we had File::mmap() which did all the work of
setting up a VMObject, and then creating a Region in the current
process's address space.
This patch simplifies the interface by removing the region part.
Files now only have to return a suitable VMObject from
vmobject_for_mmap(), and then sys$mmap() itself will take care of
actually mapping it into the address space.
This fixes an issue where we'd try to block on I/O (for inode metadata
lookup) while holding the address space spinlock. It also reduces time
spent holding the address space lock.
This forces anyone who wants to look into and/or manipulate an address
space to lock it. And this replaces the previous, more flimsy, manual
spinlock use.
Note that pointers *into* the address space are not safe to use after
you unlock the space. We've got many issues like this, and we'll have
to track those down as wlel.
We should actually start counting from the parent directory and not from
the symbolic link as it will represent a wrong count of hops from the
actual mountpoint.
The symlinks in /sys/dev/block and /sys/dev/char worked only by luck,
because I have set it to the wrong parent directory which is the
/sys/dev directory, so with the symlink it was 3 hops to /sys, together
with the root directory, therefore, everything seemed to work.
Now that the device symlinks in /sys/dev/block and /sys/dev/char are set
to the right parent directory and we start measure hops from root
directory with the parent directory of a symlink, everything seem to
work correctly now.
Now that the infrastructure of the Graphics subsystem is quite stable,
it is time to try to fix a long-standing problem, which is the lack of
locking on display connector devices. Reading and writing from multiple
processes to a framebuffer controlled by the display connector is not a
huge problem - it could be solved with POSIX locking.
The real problem is some program that will try to do ioctl operations on
a display connector without the WindowServer being aware of that which
can lead to very bad situations, for example - assuming a framebuffer is
encoded at a known resolution and certain display timings, but another
process changed the ModeSetting of the display connector, leading to
inconsistency on the properties of the current ModeSetting.
To solve this, there's a new "master" ioctl to take "ownership" and
another one to release that ownership of a display connector device. To
ensure we will not hold a Process object forever just because it has an
ownership over a display connector, we hold it with a weak reference,
and if the process is gone, someone else can take an ownership.
We are able to read the EDID from SysFS, therefore there's no need to
provide this ioctl on a DisplayConnector anymore.
Also, now we can simply require the video pledge to be set before doing
any ioctl on a DisplayConnector.
It is starting to get a little messy with how each device can try to add
or remove itself to either /sys/dev/block or /sys/dev/char directories.
To better do this, we introduce 4 virtual methods to take care of that,
so until we ensure all nodes in /sys/dev/block and /sys/dev/char are
actual symlinks, we allow the Device base class to call virtual methods
upon insertion or before being destroying, so it add itself elegantly to
either of these directories or remove itself when needed.
For special cases where we need to create symlinks, we have two virtual
methods to be called otherwise to do almost the same thing mentioned
before, but to use symlinks instead.
Under normal conditions (when mounting SysFS in /sys), there will be a
new directory in the /sys/devices directory called "graphics".
For now, under that directory there will be only a sub-directory called
"connectors" which will contain all DisplayConnectors' details, each in
its own sub-directory too, distinguished in naming with its minor
number.
Therefore, /sys/devices/graphics/connectors/MINOR_NUMBER/ will contain:
- General device attributes such as mutable_mode_setting_capable,
double_buffering_capable, flush_support, partial_flush_support and
refresh_rate_support. These values are exposed in the ioctl interface
of the DisplayConnector class too, but these can be useful later on
for command line utilities that want/need to expose these basic
settings.
- The EDID blob, simply named "edid". This will help userspace to fetch
the edid without the need of using the ioctl interface later on.
Each of these strings would previously rely on StringView's char const*
constructor overload, which would call __builtin_strlen on the string.
Since we now have operator ""sv, we can replace these with much simpler
versions. This opens the door to being able to remove
StringView(char const*).
No functional changes.
The WindowServer doesn't use this interface anymore and therefore it's
not used by any userspace application, so let's remove this stale method
to ensure we don't have to bother with it anymore.
The mmap interface was removed when we introduced the DisplayConnector
class, as it was quite unsafe to use and didn't handle switching between
graphical and text modes safely. By using the SharedFramebufferVMObject,
we are able to elegantly coordinate the switch by remapping the attached
mmap'ed-Memory::Region(s) with different mappings, therefore, keeping
WindowServer to think that the mappings it has are still valid, while
they are going to a different physical range until we are back to the
graphical mode (after a switch from text mode).
Most drivers take advantage of the fact that we know where is the actual
framebuffer in physical memory space, the SharedFramebufferVMObject is
created with that information. However, the VirtIO driver is different
in that aspect, because it relies on DMA transactions to show graphics
on the framebuffer, so the SharedFramebufferVMObject is created with
that mindset to support the arbitrary framebuffer location in physical
memory space.
This fixes a weird bug that when sometimes a user tried to switch to
console mode, the screen was frozen on graphics mode. After a hour of
debugging this, it became apparent that the problem was that we left the
y offset of the bochs graphics device in an invalid state, so it was not
zero because the WindowServer changed it, and the framebuffer console
code is not aware of horizontal and vertical offsets of the framebuffer
screen, leading to the problem that the framebuffer console updates the
first framebuffer (y offset = 0), but hardware was indicated to show the
second framebuffer (y offset = first framebuffer height).
Therefore, when doing a switch between these modes, always set the y
offset to be zero.
The DisplayConnector class is meant to replace the FramebufferDevice
class. The advantage of this class over the FramebufferDevice class is:
1. It removes the mmap interface entirely. This interface is unsafe, as
multiple processes could try to use it, and when switching to and from
text console mode, there's no "good" way to revoke a memory mapping from
this interface, let alone when there are multiple processes that call
this interface. Therefore, in the DisplayConnector class there's no
implementation for this method at all.
2. The class uses a new real-world structure called ModeSetting, which
takes into account the fact that real hardware requires more than width,
height and pitch settings to mode-set the display resolution.
3. The class assumes all instances should supply some sort of EDID,
so it facilitates such mechanism to do so. Even if a given driver does
not know what is the actual EDID, it will ask to create default-generic
EDID blob.
3. This class shifts the responsibilies of switching between console
mode and graphical mode from a GraphicsAdapter to the DisplayConnector
class, so when doing the switch, the GraphicsManagement code actually
asks each DisplayConnector object to do the switch and doesn't rely on
the GraphicsAdapter objects at all.
